Two proposals filed this fall would add 262 townhomes to the southwestern corner of South Philadelphia, one beside Girard Estate and one near Packer Park, according to Philadelphia.Today's summary of Philadelphia Business Journal reporting. It is the largest batch of new for-sale housing this part of the city has seen in years. The new homes give each buyer a garage. Neither plan gives much private outdoor space, and city design reviewers raised that point about both. If you are moving here for more room than a standard rowhome has, the decision comes down to which kind of room you want. Girard Estate's century-old twins come with porches and yards. The new townhomes come with parking built into the house.
Twins Are Scarce in Philadelphia, and They Sell Fast
Philadelphia sells mostly rowhomes. Bright MLS figures for May 1 through October 31, 2026, show 4,196 interior townhouses sold citywide at a $250,000 median, out of 7,190 total sales. Over the same six months, 990 twins sold at a $339,000 median and went under contract in a median of 14 days. Interior townhouses took a median of 21 days. Only detached houses moved faster, at 11 days, and just 424 of them sold.
Those numbers explain why the twin-and-driveway corner of South Philly gets more attention than its size would suggest. A semi-detached house with a side yard is a small slice of the city's supply, and the slice clears quickly. For the same May through October window, ZIP code 19145 posted a $295,000 median sale price with 21 days to contract, and 19148 posted $309,950 with 19 days. Both ZIP codes are mostly rowhome blocks and cut across neighborhood lines, so they set a baseline for the area rather than pricing Girard Estate or Packer Park.
Girard Estate Was Designed Around the Yard
Girard Estate dates to a philanthropic land deal. Stephen Girard left his Passyunk farm estate to the city to support Girard College. The college's trustees then hired James H. Windrim and later his son, John Torrey Windrim, to develop it for rental income. Between 1906 and 1916 they built 256 semi-detached houses, along with an apartment building and one block of rowhouses, as the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia records. The district runs roughly from 22nd to Colorado Streets and from Porter to Shunk Streets. Its houses stand apart from the surrounding rows because of their porches, front and back yards, and varied styles. The Philadelphia Historical Commission's district inventory lists the designation year as 1999 and catalogs Colonial Revival, Tudor, Mission, Craftsman, Prairie and Arts-and-Crafts designs, block by block.
Hightop Development wants to build on the district's western edge. Its proposal at 2225-27 Shunk Street would put 122 homes in 61 duplexes on a vacant lot just west of Girard Park and east of the South Philly Shopping Center, where ShopRite, Burlington and Five Below are located, the Inquirer reported. The same article described the lot as one of the few large developable parcels in an area that has seen little new housing even as neighborhoods to the north boomed. The parcel used to be part of Cedar Realty Trust's larger plan to turn the auto-oriented shopping area into a residential and commercial hub. That plan ended during the pandemic.
Hightop's design, by Studio HS4, uses four-story buildings about 45 feet tall. One home would take floors one and two, and a second home would take floors three and four. The units would be about 2,000 to 2,200 square feet, according to the presentation at the city's October 6 Civic Design Review meeting. Each home gets ground-floor parking, with 124 spaces in total. The Inquirer reported that local community leaders were mixed on the plan. Some welcomed new homes on the long-vacant parcel, and others hoped for a design closer to the early 20th-century twins to the east.
Packer Park Was Designed Around the Car
Packer Park grew up in the opposite order. The original homes date to the 1950s, and Brinton Estates followed in the 1990s. The Reserve at Packer Park added 230 townhouses between 2003 and 2007, and Siena Place added 313 three-story townhomes in 2008. Cul-de-sacs, garages, driveways and off-street parking run through all of it. The top of this market reaches well past the citywide twin median. On June 1, 2026, a new-build home on Renaissance Walk sold for $1.32 million. It has three bedrooms, four baths and 3,201 square feet. That is one sale, but it shows how high a new garage townhome here can price.
Southpointe follows the same model. Trove Capital bought a former Philadelphia Housing Authority warehouse site at 3100 Penrose Ferry Road, just northwest of FDR Park, for $8.5 million in June. It plans a gated community of 140 townhomes in 28 clusters, each home with two parking spaces, the Inquirer reported. The plan calls for 116 three-story and 24 four-story homes with two-car garages, a dog park, a playground, basketball and pickleball courts, and an outdoor gym. Prices are expected to start around $800,000. Barbara Capozzi, who heads the Packer Park Civic Association, told the Inquirer: "It fits in well. It's a very tough crowd down here, but they were satisfied. They signed off on it."
The Three Options Side by Side
| Girard Estate twin | Hightop at 2225-27 Shunk St. | Southpointe at 3100 Penrose Ferry Rd. | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Built or proposed | Built 1906 to 1916 | Proposed fall 2026 | Proposed fall 2026 |
| Format | Semi-detached house | Stacked duplex, two homes per building, four stories | Three- and four-story townhomes in clusters |
| Parking | On-street or private, varies by house | One garage space per home, 124 total | Two-car garage, plus 141 shared surface spaces |
| Outdoor space | Porch, front yard and backyard | Shared landscaping and a green buffer | Shared amenities: dog park, playground, courts |
| Price signal | Citywide twin median $339,000, May through October 2026 | A neighbor at the Oct. 6 review estimated about $500,000 | Expected to start around $800,000 |
The twin median is a citywide figure, and the Hightop number is one neighbor's estimate from a public meeting. Treat both as rough ranges. The 1906 houses were built with private yards. The two proposals put their open space into shared areas and parking.
Design Reviewers Raised Outdoor Space on Both Projects
Both projects went before the city's Civic Design Review committee on October 6, and the committee's comments show the trade a buyer would be making.
For Southpointe, the committee's October 20 findings letter describes 140 townhomes with 421 parking spaces on a parcel zoned CMX-3. The committee "lamented the lack of outdoor space for the individual units." It suggested more central amenity spaces, narrower internal streets with more room for sidewalks and street trees, and better alley paving. The letter states that review of that project is complete. Before the meeting, the developer's attorney told the Inquirer that the team hoped to start demolishing the old warehouses right after it.
The Hightop review went differently. Staff and committee members criticized the tight layout, the car-focused internal circulation, the limited green space, and building fronts that faced neighbors' backyards. They suggested reorienting buildings and improving pedestrian paths. One committee member praised the for-sale model and criticized the lack of private outdoor space. The committee then voted unanimously to continue the review of 2225 Shunk Street rather than conclude it. If you are considering one of these homes, expect the Shunk Street design to change before anything goes on sale.
What a Buyer Should Weigh This Winter
Both projects are still proposals. Until either one reaches the market, a buyer here is comparing existing houses: Girard Estate twins, Packer Park's 1950s homes and its 2000s townhomes. Twins went under contract in a median of 14 days citywide from May through October 2026, so a well-priced one is unlikely to sit for long.
The nearby investment explains why developers are building garages here. Both proposal sites are within three miles of the Navy Yard and the Bellwether District, where thousands of new jobs are expected. PIDC announced a $30 million state grant in May 2025 to prepare 54 acres of the Navy Yard's Greenway District for up to 700,000 square feet of advanced manufacturing and commercial space. Stateside Live! held the grand opening for its $20-million-plus expansion on May 29, 2026. A state plan announced May 28, 2026 puts nearly $30 million into traffic improvements around the sports complex, including a new I-76 entrance ramp, with near-term projects targeted for completion by the end of 2028. At FDR Park, the Gateway Plaza, the Anna C. Verna Playground and the Welcome Center have opened, Billy Penn reported. The Fairmount Park Conservancy's schedule runs the park's Picnic & Play phase to 2030.
There is also a pending zoning proposal. On November 12, Council members introduced a zoning overlay for five South Broad Street subway stations, including Snyder and Oregon, that could increase housing capacity near those stops, the Inquirer reported. It has not passed. The car-oriented projects and the transit overlay point in different directions. Both suggest this corner of South Philly will keep adding housing on its few large parcels.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Girard Estate homes rowhomes? Most are semi-detached. The district's 1906 to 1916 construction produced 256 twins, plus one apartment building and a single block of rowhouses.
Which Packer Park developments have garages? Garages, driveways and off-street parking run through Packer Park, including the Reserve at Packer Park and Siena Place. Southpointe would add two-car garages to each of its 140 homes.
Is Girard Estate a historic district? Yes. The Philadelphia Historical Commission's inventory lists its designation in 1999.
If you are weighing a Girard Estate twin with a yard against waiting for a garage townhome near FDR Park, Michael Prince can walk both blocks with you and price the trade house by house. If you already own a twin in this corner of South Philly, start with a valuation, or list with Michael while buyers are still competing for the few twins on the market.